top of page
Search

How to Choose a Charity: A Practical Checklist for Donors

Nov 14
10 min read

Donor comparing charity reports at home

Choose a charity by running it through five checks: Is its mission specific? Is it legally registered? Do its financial reports show where the money goes? Can it show results? Are its donation claims precise enough to confirm? A charity that passes all five is a sound choice. You can run the whole check in under an hour, and the effort matters most when giving to Ukraine, where fake appeals multiplied after the invasion. We built our shop around the same checks. We partner with Ukrainian designers and donate a portion of net profits to Ukrainian charities, and we publish a transparency report so you can see how that support works.



TL;DR

 

  • Pick a cause first, then compare a few charities working on it. A mission that names who is helped, what problem is solved and how is a good sign.

  • Confirm the exact legal entity is registered, then read its latest annual report and financial filings, not just its homepage.

  • Look for results (outcomes), not only activity (outputs): reports, outside evaluations and multi-year trends.

  • Treat “100% goes to the cause” and “a portion of sales” as claims to confirm: ask what percentage, of what figure, to which named charity.

  • For Ukraine, favor organizations with a real presence on the ground, and check for lookalike names and websites.

 

Table of Contents

 

 

Start with the cause, then compare a few charities

 

The most common mistake is picking a charity by who sent the most emotional appeal. Start the other way around. Decide what you want to change: emergency relief, medical care, education, refugee support, animals, culture. Then shortlist three or four charities that work on it.

 

Orange County Community Foundation’s guide to vetting nonprofits suggests reading the mission statement for three things: who is served, what problem is addressed, and how change will be created. “We help communities thrive” tells you almost nothing. “We deliver emergency food and water to displaced families in frontline regions” tells you a lot, and you can check it against what the charity actually reports doing.


Three checks for evaluating a charity mission

Also ask whether the charity’s size fits its goals. A small group promising to end a national crisis is a different proposition from an experienced organization with programs in the places it names.

 

Check that the charity is real and registered

 

Before you read any numbers, confirm who is asking for the money. CharityWatch’s guide to researching charities says to confirm the exact legal entity asking for the donation, verify its tax-exempt status, find its most recent financial reporting, and check with state charity regulators.

 

In the United States that means:

 

  1. Find the charity’s full legal name and its employer identification number (EIN), usually in the footer of its website or on its donation page.

  2. Search for it in the IRS tax-exempt organization database to confirm it is a recognized 501©(3). That status is what makes a gift tax-deductible for most donors.

  3. Look up its state registration if your state requires charities that solicit donations to register.

 

If you live elsewhere, the principle is the same. A guide from the Centre for Democracy and Rule of Law lists verification databases by country, including the UK Charity Commission register and a global directory of validated charities and NGOs searchable by name or country. Rules differ by country, so always attribute a tax rule to the country it comes from. A gift that is deductible in the US may not be in your home country.

 

Read the finances like a donor, not an accountant

 

In the US, most charities file an annual return called Form 990. It shows revenue, expenses and how much goes to programs. You do not need accounting training to get value from it. Look for four things:

 

  • Program spending. The Orange County guide says program spending of roughly 65 to 75 percent of expenses is generally considered appropriate. Treat that as a rough range, not a pass/fail line. A young charity or one running a big campaign can look different in a single year.

  • Trends over several years. One year can mislead. Look for repeated deficits or sudden swings in revenue.

  • Reserves and liabilities. The California Community Foundation’s donor guide points to revenue diversification, liabilities and multi-year deficits as signs of how sustainable a charity is.

  • Audits. Larger organizations should have independent audited statements, and ethics and conflict-of-interest policies should be public.

 

Low overhead alone does not make a charity good. A group can spend little on administration and still accomplish little. That is why the next check matters.

 

Look for results, not just activity

 

A charity can report that it distributed 10,000 meals (an output). A stronger report explains what changed for the people who received them (an outcome). Fidelity Charitable’s guidance on evaluating charities gives a clear example: tracking not only how many people completed job training but how often it led to employment.

 

What to look for in an annual or impact report:

 

  • Goals stated in advance, then progress measured against them.

  • Numbers broken down by program and location, with funding amounts per program.

  • Evaluation by someone outside the charity, or at least a clear description of how results were measured.

  • Honest accounts of what did not work.

 

GiveWell’s advice on researching charities on your own adds a useful question: what would your additional donation actually do? Look for how a charity plans to use new funds, and whether it has room to put them to work.

 

Testimonials and photos are fine as color, but they are not evidence on their own. Systematic data is.

 

Watch for warning signs in the appeal itself

 

Most problems show up in how a charity asks for money. These patterns deserve a pause:

 

  • Pressure to give immediately, or to pay in cash, gift cards or by wire.

  • A name or website that looks almost identical to a well-known organization.

  • No named leadership, no contact details, or no financial reports.

  • A very new page with little history, and comments that are switched off or deleted.

  • Emotional images with no specifics about what the money will do.

 

The Ukraine action guide above also advises checking the person who contacts you, not only the organization, and treating pressure for immediate funds or offers that seem too good to be true as classic scam signals.

 

How to evaluate charities helping Ukraine

 

The scale of the response to the war is the reason to be careful. CSIS analysts report that the UN’s humanitarian coordination office identified 461 humanitarian partners in Ukraine, and that at least 1,700 local NGOs had formed since the invasion. They also cite a BBC investigation that found hundreds of fake charities copying the branding of real ones. Most organizations are genuine, but the number of options and the number of imitators are both large.

 

A practical routine for Ukraine giving:

 

  1. Check for real presence. Give.org’s Ukraine relief tips advise checking whether a charity already has a presence in Ukraine and preferring experienced disaster-relief organizations. Its website should describe current activities in the country, not only reuse images of the crisis.

  2. Look for accreditation. The same guidance recommends verifying compliance with the BBB’s charity standards on Give.org. Its one-year-later guidance suggests donating to established, US-based charities that are BBB Accredited, which you can check on the site or with a local BBB.

  3. Search for lookalikes. The Ukraine action guide says to search for organizations with similar names or websites, since mimicking organizations are likely scams. Check the website’s mission, team and contact details, and review any published financial reports and funding sources.

  4. Remember refugees abroad. People displaced from Ukraine are served by organizations working in neighboring countries, not only inside Ukraine. Decide which need you want to help. Our guide on helping Ukrainian refugees walks through ways that work, and our piece on humanitarian aid donations explains how to give so the help reaches Ukraine.

  5. Be careful with crowdfunding. Give.org advises giving to people you know when it comes to crowdfunding appeals.

 

Transparency is also becoming the standard Ukrainian groups are measured against. The CSIS authors argue that NGOs in Ukraine should publish their donors and partnerships, run open bank accounts that publish transactions, and undergo periodic public audits. When you see a Ukrainian organization doing those things, that is a positive signal.

 

What “100% goes to the cause” really means

 

A promise that every dollar reaches the cause sounds ideal, but the arithmetic needs explaining. Give.org says such a claim is credible only with an explanation of how it is accomplished, for example disclosure that board members or major donors cover overhead. Without that, it may be misleading.

 

CharityWatch explains why: “every dollar donated” and “every dollar spent” are different ratios, and restricted funds, multi-year pledges and program revenue make a clean 100% figure often impossible to calculate. Give.org’s Ukraine tips add that credit card donations incur processing fees, so a real 100% claim needs a clear account of who pays them.

 

A documented enforcement case shows why this matters. The California Attorney General announced a settlement with a veterans charity that claimed all donations went to wounded veterans. The investigation found it spent an average of 16% of revenue on programs, and the charity paid $95,000 in restitution.

 

A simple test: when you see a 100% claim, look for the sentence that explains how running costs are paid. If it is there, the claim is better supported. If it is not, look at the charity’s financial report instead.


What "100% goes to the cause" really means

How to read charity claims on products you buy

 

Many people support causes by buying: a shirt, a mug, a tote bag. It is a legitimate way to give, and it works best when you know what is promised. Four questions turn a vague promise into a clear one:

 

  1. Which charity? The product page should name the organization, so you can look it up in an official register or on the charity’s own channels.

  2. What share, of what? A donation can be a fixed amount per item, a percentage of the price, or a percentage of profit. Each is a different number. As CharityWatch explains with a $50 item and $43 of costs, 10% of a $7 profit is 70 cents. Know which kind of promise you are looking at.

  3. Is there a time limit or cap? Campaign dates and maximums should be stated.

  4. Is there a report? A seller that publishes how much it donated and to whom gives you something to check after the purchase.

 

It also helps to treat the purchase as a purchase. The product should be worth the price on its own terms: quality, design and service. The donation is the added good.

 

We publish a transparency reporting page so shoppers can see how our support for Ukraine works, and our about page explains who we are. If you want to know more about an order or our approach, you can contact us directly.

 

A step-by-step routine you can finish in an hour

 

Here is the whole process in order:

 

  1. Define the need you want to address in one sentence.

  2. Shortlist three charities that work on it, using accreditation lists and recommendations from people you trust.

  3. Confirm registration of each legal entity and its tax status in your country.

  4. Open the latest annual report and filing. Note program spending, multi-year trends and any audit.

  5. Look for outcomes, not only outputs, and for outside evaluation.

  6. Read the appeal for pressure, lookalike names and unexplained claims.

  7. Contact them with one question. Fidelity Charitable notes that reaching out to a smaller charity shows how it treats donors, and an honest, timely answer is itself a good sign.

  8. Decide how much and how often. A recurring gift gives a charity predictable funds, and you can review it each year.

 

Keep a record of what you checked. If your giving is large, say so to the charity and to your tax adviser, who can tell you what is deductible where you live.

 

Support Ukraine with something you will use

 

If part of your giving is buying with purpose, our shop is built for that. Every design is created with local Ukrainian designers and features real Ukrainian symbols and messages rather than generic graphics. We donate a portion of net profits to trustworthy Ukrainian charities, and shipping is free worldwide.


Weukraine

You can browse T-shirts, hats and gifts, or go straight to tote bags and enamel mugs and bottles. Looking for something for someone else? Our guide to buying Ukraine merch covers choosing well, and the gifts and accessories page has smaller options.

 

Our perspective

 

Choosing a charity is not about finding a perfect organization. It is about giving with open eyes. We started We Ukraine because people around the world wanted a visible, daily way to say they stand with Ukraine, and because Ukrainian designers had stories and symbols worth sharing.   We think support works best when it is layered. A direct gift to a vetted charity is one layer. Wearing a design that carries a real Ukrainian symbol, or giving a mug to a friend and explaining what the trident means, is another. It keeps the conversation going and keeps people engaged long after the headlines move on.   That is why we work only with local Ukrainian designers, why we donate a portion of net profits to trustworthy Ukrainian charities, and why we publish a transparency page. We want you to ask good questions of every cause you support, including ours, and we are glad to answer them.   Dmytro

 

FAQ

 

What is the most important thing to check before donating?

 

Confirm that the exact legal entity is registered and recognized as a charity in your country. In the US, that means searching the IRS tax-exempt database. After that, read its latest annual report to see what it did with its money.

 

How much of my donation should go to programs?

 

There is no single legal threshold. A common guideline from community foundation guidance is roughly 65 to 75 percent of expenses on programs, judged over several years. Look at the trend and at what the programs achieve, not just one year’s ratio.

 

How do I find trustworthy charities for Ukraine?

 

Prefer experienced organizations with a current, documented presence in Ukraine or in the countries hosting refugees. Verify them with an accreditation service such as Give.org, and search for lookalike names before you give. Be cautious with unfamiliar crowdfunding pages.

 

How can I verify a charity claim on a product?

 

Look for the named charity, the amount or share promised, any dates or limits, and a report of what was donated. Then look up the charity in an official register or on its own channels. The more precise the claim, the easier it is to confirm.

 

Is a “100% of donations” promise a good sign?

 

It can be, if the charity explains how running costs and payment fees are covered. Without that explanation, look at the financial report to see where the money actually goes.

 

Sources

 

Recommended

 

 
 
 

Comments


©2026

Private Enterpreneur: Dmytro Grama

Address:  Gran via Jaume I, Girona, Spain

Email: orders@weukraine.com

Phone: +34610185844

​

Slava Ukraini! Stand with Ukraine. 
Also by us: Wooray, matching merch for groups

Mastercard accepted
Visa accepted
PCI DSS secure payments
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
bottom of page